Minsky Robotics

Finding the broken main that serves a hospital district

After an earthquake, a utility crew trying to restore water to a hospital district has two possible sites for a buried break. The first pair of readings fits both.

Explore the Sheffield recordings
Inspectors approach a buckled tank at a water treatment plant in Calexico, California, after the 2010 earthquake.
Calexico, California, after the 2010 earthquake. Adam DuBrowa, FEMA
Two pipes could be leaking. A mobile pickup takes a second reading to distinguish the break on the north or south branch.

Where should a robot listen when one leak could be on either pipe?

Utilities locate leaks in pressurized pipes by comparing when the sound of escaping water reaches two sensors. In this model a leak on either side of a pipe junction would give the same difference in arrival times at the first two listening points.

The mobile pickup moves to the point where the two possible breaks predict the largest difference in arrival times. A new reading identifies the branch for the crew to inspect. If the reading never arrives, both branches stay on the map.

How we would test it

Hide the break location from an experienced utility crew and from the robots. Give both the same detectors, pipe map and access points. Record how many visits each needs to identify the damaged branch, how long it takes and whether either sends a crew to the wrong street. Repeat with a missing reading to see whether the robots can leave the location unresolved.

Sources

Mine rescue after a collapse

A scout can squeeze through a gap in the rubble that would trap a rescue sled on the way out.

Test the return route
A flooded mine passage with fallen timbers at Sharkham Point in Devon.
Sharkham Point Iron Mine in Devon, England. JLParton
A scout finds a route around a roof fall and a tracked carrier brings a miner out on a sled.

Can the loaded sled make the turn that the scout just cleared?

NIOSH funded tracked scouts that relay images from damaged mines. The CERBERUS research team later demonstrated underground robots that shared a map and planned routes for machines of different sizes.

The animated rescue shows one route out. In the return-route test you can move the fallen slab and see whether the loaded sled clears the shortcut, needs the wider turn or has to wait.

Sources

Surveying a bridge pier after a flood

After a flood, an engineer deciding whether ambulances can use a bridge needs to know how much riverbed has washed away around its foundations. The footing can hide part of the damage from sonar.

A USGS technician pilots a small survey boat beside bridge piers on the Payette River in Idaho.
A USGS survey on the Payette River near Letha, Idaho. Paul V. Schauer, USGS
A survey boat passes a bridge pier. Its sonar marks the depression that floodwater has cut beside the footing.

Where should the boat cross again to see behind the footing?

USGS crews have piloted survey boats from the riverbank and used overlapping sonar passes to reduce blind spots. The model shows a first crossing over the hole beside the footing.

Given one more crossing, the boat would choose an angle that brings the hidden riverbed into view. A map marking any ground that remains unseen would show the bridge engineer where to inspect before deciding whether traffic can return.

Sources

Inspecting the underside of a waste tank

Inspectors watching for leaks that could reach groundwater need to know whether a change in a waste tank’s floor comes from thinning steel or from the measurement itself.

Archival overhead view of circular waste tanks at Hanford before burial.
Waste tanks under construction at Hanford, Washington. U.S. Department of Energy
A crawler presses its probe against two places on the tank floor. The ultrasonic return travels a shorter distance through the thinner steel.

Does the thin spot persist when the crawler lifts and resets its probe?

At Hanford operators use ultrasound to measure steel through narrow slots beneath a tank. In a separate study of Hanford tank walls, researchers found that changes between inspections could reflect differences in how the measurements were taken.

The model shows the first two readings. The proposed crawler would reseat its probe and measure the surrounding steel so the inspector could see whether the same thin patch appears again.

Sources

Measuring the ocean beneath a hurricane

Hurricane forecasters need to know how deep warm water extends beneath a storm that could strengthen before landfall. Two ocean models can put the bottom of that layer at different depths.

Hurricane Milton over the Gulf of Mexico from the International Space Station in October 2024.
The eye of Hurricane Milton on October 7, 2024. NASA
An underwater glider samples the warm surface layer and the colder water below, then surfaces to transmit its temperature profile.
Opening photograph of Hurricane Milton from the International Space Station, courtesy of NASA.

Where should a glider dive when ocean models disagree?

NOAA gliders already send temperature profiles when they surface. Pilots can consult maps that show where forecasts differ on the heat stored in the ocean and how fast the water is moving.

At its next surfacing the proposed glider would choose a dive it could reach in the current before the storm passed. The test is whether that dive gives forecasters a better estimate of the heat available to the hurricane than a dive along the original course.

Sources